Development Intent
Planning AtlasMertonMerton ParkApplication
Planning Application

23/P0541

MYDENTIST LONDON ROAD MORDEN, 18 London Road, Morden, Merton, SM4 5BQ

Full / Other PlanningMerton Park ward
Submission
23 Feb 2023
Target
15 May 2023
Decision
15 May 2023
Outcome
Refused
Delegated decisionRefused
15 May 2023
Decided by Martin Miranda Antelo under delegated powers
Loading map…
Scheme description

PART DEMOLITION AND ERECTION OF A REAR EXTENSION OF EXISTING GROUND FLOOR COMMERCIAL UNIT (USE CLASS E) AND FIRST FLOOR REAR EXTENSION AND CONVERSION FROM OFFICE TO RESIDENTIAL UNIT CREATING 1 X 1 BEDROOM FLAT (USE CLASS C3) WITH PROVISION OF ACCESS AT FIRST FLOOR, REFUSE AND CYCLE STORAGE.

Why it was refused
Reason 1

In the absence of satisfactory evidence to demonstrate the lack of demand for the continued use of the Class E use in existing or alternative employment generating and/or community uses, the loss of office floor space in a sustainable location is considered to adversely impact on the vitality and viability of the Morden District town centre and Core Shopping frontage. The scheme is contrary to the aims and objectives of, in particular, policies DM E3 and DM R4 of the Adopted Merton Sites and Polices Plan (2014) and policies CS3 and CS12 of Core Strategy (2011).

Reason 2

In the absence of an Air Quality Neutral Statement, it has not be satisfactorily demonstrated that the development would be air quality neutral, thereby failing to comply with the aims and objectives of, in particular, policy S1 of the London Plan 2021.

Reason 3

In the absence of satisfactory separated commercial and residential refuse storage, the scheme is considered to result in substandard layout to the detriment of the free flow of traffic in the locality and highway and pedestrian safety. The scheme is contrary to, in particular, Merton Core Strategy (2011) Policy CS17 and London Plan (2021) Policies SI 7 and SI 8

Reason 4

The proposed walkway at roof level and associated railings by reason of its combined siting, design and length results in an incongruous and unsympathetic form of development that fails to relate to the appearance of the site and the terrace row that the site forms a part of and the visual amenity of the locality. The proposal thus fails to comply with the aims and objectives of, in particular, Policy CS14 of the Merton Core Strategy (2011), Policies DM D1 and DM D2 of Merton's Sites and Policies Plan (2014) and London Plan policy D3.

Policies cited
R4
CS3
CS12
S1
CS17
SI7
SI8
CS14
D2
Parties
Applicant
Patel Property Ltd
Timeline
23 Feb 2023
Application submitted
15 May 2023
Delegated decision: Refused
Supporting documents · 16
Metal Railing Specification.pdfView ↗
Proposed Plans Revision A Amended 24.04.2023.pdfView ↗
Existing Plans Revision A Amended 24.04.2023.pdfView ↗
CIL Form Amended 24.04.2023.pdfView ↗
Application Form Amended 24.04.2023.pdfView ↗
Site Location Plan and Block Plan.pdfView ↗
ApplicationFormRedacted.pdfView ↗
Appeal Decision.pdfView ↗
Delivery and Servicing Note.pdfView ↗
External Lighting to Rear.pdfView ↗
Existing and Proposed Floor PlansView ↗
Decision Notice.pdfView ↗
Delegated Report.pdfView ↗
Planning and Design and Access Statement.pdfView ↗
CIL Form 1.pdfView ↗
Proposed Elevations and Section Revision A Amended 24.04.202View ↗
View Application Page ↗
Data from the Merton planning register.
Summary
Reference
23/P0541
Type
Full Planning Permission
Applicant
Patel Property Ltd
Submitted
23 Feb 2023
Decision date
15 May 2023
Council
Decision
Refused
Decision route
Delegated (officer)
How long, really
12
wks · this application
Submission → decision · 4 wks over the 8-week target