Development Intent
Planning AtlasBarnetWoodhouseApplication
Planning Application

23/1194/FUL

Garages Rear Of 2 Churchfield Avenue London N12 0NT

Full / Other PlanningWoodhouse wardSmoke Control Zone: Finchley No.10
Submission
20 Mar 2023
Target
17 May 2023
Decision
1 Jul 2024
Outcome
Refused
Delegated decisionRefused
1 Jul 2024
Decided by Emily Bell under delegated powers
Loading map…
Scheme description

Demolition of 4no. garages and erection of single storey building plus 1no storey basement level for storage use.

Why it was refused
Reason 1

The proposed development, by reason of its scale, siting in a residential area and its use, would cause undue noise and disturbance and would be out of keeping with the surrounding residential area , to the detriment of the residential amenities of the occupiers of neighbouring properties. The proposal would therefore be contrary to Policies CS NPPF, CS1 and CS5 of the Local Plan Core Strategy (adopted September 2012), Policy DM01 and DM14 of the Development Management Policies DPD (adopted September 2012), and the Sustainable Design and Construction SPD (2016).

Reason 2

The proposed development would by reason of its height, siting and elevated position due to the levels of the site, appear as a prominent and visually obtrusive feature when viewed from the adjacent listed building, Christ Church. Further, insufficient and inaccurate information has been provided with regards to the impacts of the proposed development on the structural integrity of the adjacent listed building. The proposal would therefore have significant adverse impacts on the adjacent statutory listed building, contrary to Policy CS5 of Barnet's Core Strategy DPD (2012); Policies DM01, DM06 and DM18 of Barnet's Development Management Policies DPD (2012) and the guidance contained within the National Planning Policy Framework (2023).

Policies cited
CS1
CS5
DM01
DM14
NPPF
DM06
DM18
Parties
Applicant
Mr Hussein Hassani
Officer
Emily Bell
Appeal
Appeal Dismissed
Outcome: Dismissed
Timeline
20 Mar 2023
Application submitted
22 Mar 2023
Application validated
1 Jul 2024
Delegated decision: Refused
Appeal: Appeal Dismissed
Supporting documents · 35
125 of 35
DELEGATED REPORT4 Jul 2024View ↗
DN: REFUSE FUL1 Jul 2024View ↗
2A CHURCHFIELD AVENUE16 Apr 2024View ↗
BASEMENT IMPACT ASSESSMENT16 Feb 2024View ↗
6 CHURCHFIELD AVENUE16 Nov 2023View ↗
EXISTING GROUND FLOOR PLAN23 May 2023View ↗
EXISTING ELEVATIONS23 May 2023View ↗
REVISED PROPOSED GROUND FLOOR PLAN23 May 2023View ↗
REVISED PROPOSED BASEMENT PLAN23 May 2023View ↗
REVISED PROPOSED ELEVATIONS23 May 2023View ↗
REVISED PROPOSED SECTION A23 May 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)26 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)24 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)24 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)22 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)22 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)20 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)20 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)20 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)20 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)19 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)19 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)18 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)11 Apr 2023View ↗
COMMENT(FULL)6 Apr 2023View ↗
View Application Page ↗
Data from the Barnet planning register.
Summary
Reference
23/1194/FUL
Type
Full Application
Applicant
Mr Hussein Hassani
Submitted
20 Mar 2023
Decision date
1 Jul 2024
Officer
Council
Decision
Refused
Decision route
Delegated (officer)
How long, really
67
wks · this application
Submission → decision · 59 wks over the 8-week target
Public response
Objections
10
In support
9
Total comments
19